First Time Anal (2012)

The Hottest Gay Hunks Around

These guys might be straight but they were willing to take a cock in the ass for our cameras for the very first time. It took a lot of lube, a lot of cash, and a lot of persuading to get these gay4pay muscle studs to open wide for their very first dicks. Watch military bodybuilder Trevor Mustang get plowed by Rod Barry, watch Ryan Andrews rail Andy Hunter, watch Kody Henshaw pile drive Dustin Alexanders, watch Cypher drill Erin O'Shay, and watch Justin Riddick nail Blaze!

Cast (10)CrewGenresDetailsReleasesMediaAwards

Andy Hunter

Erin Hart

Justin Riddick

Kody

Rod Barry

Trevor Mustang

Blaze

Cypher

Dustin

Ryan Andrews

If you liked First Time Anal, you might also like…

88% match

Eating Out 2: Sloppy Seconds

2006

87% match

Tongues Untied

1990

80% match

King Cobra

2016

78% match

Port Authority

2019

73% match

Your Friends & Neighbors

1998

70% match

The Fluffer

2001

67% match

Orgazmo

1998

64% match

Magic Mike XXL

2015

60% match

Don Jon

2013

60% match

Magic Mike

2012

60% match

Pecker

1998

60% match

Porno

2019

60% match

Barely Legal

2003

60% match

The Bachelor and the Bobby-Soxer

1947

60% match

Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex *But Were Afraid to Ask

1972

60% match

Different for Girls

1996

60% match

Life

2015

60% match

4th Man Out

2015

60% match

Welcome to Chechnya

2020

60% match

Pillion

2025

Similar films

Leave It to Levi

2019

The Lake House

2020

The Fall of Communism as Seen in Gay Pornography

1998

The Fluffer

2001

Young Rose Tribe Show 03: Season of Awakening

Tips

2016

Young HOMO Show 02: Summer Time

I'm a Porn Star

2013

Bulgarian Lovers

2003

Hairy Horndogs #3

2006

Mondo Homo: A Study of French Gay Porn in the '70s

2014

The Ages of Lulu

1990