Sinister Secret Ingredient (2026)

When dentist Mel buys a small-town clinic to start a new life, she meets Ruth, a beloved baker and neighbor with a tragic past. But when Mel’s 12-year-old daughter Abby goes missing, Mel uncovers Ruth’s horrifying secret.

Cast (14)CrewGenresDetailsReleasesMediaAwards

S

Sabrina Miller

Mel

Ginger Gilmartin

Ruth

Justin Ross Martin

Nick

G

Gwen Mowdy

Abby

Barbara Sandlin

Barb

Ed Spinelli

The Neighbor

Betsy Hume

Janine

Ryan Francis

Robert

Jobie James

Police Officer

B

Brandi Price

Sergeant Rourke

D

Darron Dunbar

Patient

K

Kinlee Williams

Oakley

D

Derek Egede

Neighborhood Civilian

L

Lorrie Chilcoat

Britney

If you liked Sinister Secret Ingredient, you might also like…

88% match

The Twin

2017

88% match

The Neighbor in the Window

2020

82% match

Hello

2022

78% match

The Hound of the Baskervilles

2002

78% match

A Sister's Secret

2018

72% match

Seeds of Yesterday

2015

67% match

180

2026

65% match

Kept Woman

2015

63% match

Locke & Key

2011

60% match

Suburbicon

2017

60% match

Bad Girl

2016

60% match

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play

2019

60% match

Infidelity in Suburbia

2017

60% match

A Bundle of Trouble: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

2017

60% match

The Locksmith

2023

60% match

Riddled with Deceit: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

2020

60% match

Mommy Would Never Hurt You

2019

60% match

If There Be Thorns

2015

60% match

Miss Marple: They Do It with Mirrors

1991

60% match

Is There a Killer in My Family?

2020