Too Pretty to Live (2016)

On January 31, 2012, engaged couple Billy Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth are found murdered in their Mountain City, Tennessee home. As police investigate, the story takes a shocking turn when the admitted shooter claims the crime was a sanctioned hit ordered by a rogue CIA agent. Authorities dig deeper, but find no record of the agent, and actually discover that the killers have been catfished. Who is behind the fabricated government official? Ripped from the pages of renowned prosecutor Dennis Brooks' new book, TOO PRETTY TO LIVE is a story of betrayal, vengeance, and two overly-protective parents manipulated into committing murder.

If you liked Too Pretty to Live, you might also like…

89% match

A Toxic Love Story

2026

87% match

The Assassination of Jesse James: Death of an Outlaw

2008

85% match

Come See Me in the Good Light

2025

78% match

Evil Influencer: The Jodi Hildebrandt Story

2025

77% match

The Class of ‘92

2013

77% match

My Mom Jayne

2025

72% match

28 Up

1984

64% match

Naqoyqatsi

2002

60% match

Scotty and the Secret History of Hollywood

2018

61% match

Above Majestic

2018

60% match

Birth of the Living Dead

2013

60% match

Voyeur

2017

60% match

Capital in the Twenty-First Century

2019

60% match

Directed by John Ford

1971

60% match

To Kill a Tiger

2023

60% match

Heart of a Dog

2015

60% match

Beyoncé: Life Is But a Dream

2013

60% match

McQueen

2018

60% match

Anna Nicole Smith: You Don't Know Me

2023

60% match

American Boy: A Profile of Steven Prince

1978